$500 half day $700 full or $200 a man. $75 room on water! No minimum

  • Home
  • 2023 season
  • Turnaments
  • Comedy show
  • 2024
  • Boat 2025
  • More
    • Home
    • 2023 season
    • Turnaments
    • Comedy show
    • 2024
    • Boat 2025
  • Home
  • 2023 season
  • Turnaments
  • Comedy show
  • 2024
  • Boat 2025

Second Choice Charters Montauk NY fish with Captain Jeff Nichols

Second Choice Charters Montauk NY fish with Captain Jeff NicholsSecond Choice Charters Montauk NY fish with Captain Jeff NicholsSecond Choice Charters Montauk NY fish with Captain Jeff Nichols

All pictures from  2022- 2024: Reeltime! 

60 documented trips last year all successful! 

fast, 28 mph highly productive boat!

Book now here
Striped bass, Tuna, fluke,seabass,black fish

631 466 7223

Second Choice Charters Montauk NY fish with Captain Jeff Nichols

Second Choice Charters Montauk NY fish with Captain Jeff NicholsSecond Choice Charters Montauk NY fish with Captain Jeff NicholsSecond Choice Charters Montauk NY fish with Captain Jeff Nichols

All pictures from  2022- 2024: Reeltime! 

60 documented trips last year all successful! 

fast, 28 mph highly productive boat!

Book now here
Striped bass, Tuna, fluke,seabass,black fish

631 466 7223

ItOr  friend big Glen
world famous Texas Angler
look how calm
bottom fishing or specialty
Mahi Mahi Mahi!! So much fun on light tackle.
East Hampton High school trip ....NO CELL PHONES.
I can put you in this picture!
Show More
    Common August.september

    Captain Jeff

    Top-Notch Equipment

    Flexible Options

    That's me last year 2023, not pretty, but the fish is. 92 pound blue fin tuna.. All pictures on this site are from 2023....what's the point of viewing old picks, from past year?  I won't take you if i don"t think you will catch a lot of fish. My customers come for food:fresh fish.

    For years as a guide in Montauk  I guaranteed a 40 pound striped bass on night trips or trip was free; I never had to give away trip. 


    I have fished Montauk Now for 25 years. I am also on fishbooker.com.  I'm one of the  top, part-time 4 man charter boats in Montauk. There are nicer boats. Mine is a narrow and loud diesel. ( I can direct you to quitter cleaner boats.) MY only goal is to bend the rods and fill coolers. NO captain in Montauk knows the tides like I do( by-the-way-  useless info in my opinion, id rather know stuff about the stock market or building houses then I would have to be making this  stupid site) anyway, I was a night time bass fisherman for 25 years in Montauk,  100 night a year , every year. That's ALL I did. Im not proud; its just a fact. I did not  go bars , or parties. All I did was fish at night ....and got good at catching huge striped bass, but know matter how good we think we are the fish.. The fish are the true stars of the show, with out them i am nothing. we must respect them. 

    Meet Our Captains

    Flexible Options

    Top-Notch Equipment

    Flexible Options

    We offer a variety of charter options, including half-day, full-day, and overnight trips. We can also customize your trip to suit your preferences and needs. The  marine life off Montauk  has been amazing..esp Whales!  in September im one of  the only boats that only targets specifically Mahi Mahi..a tropical fish that is abundant sometimes as close as 20 miles off the beach.. we fill coolers! Fun light tackle!! And  good eats

    Look at the picture Gallery all fish are from last season. I keep the price as low as possible ($200 a man inshore)  because it's a small no- thrills boat. but we do have a bean bag.There much nicer boats in Montauk, but my Three Sons is fast @16 knots cruise..



    I've placed in several tournaments over the years,  Won White water Marines in shore division,  and last year 2023 won the charter boat Black fish division in MAC  fall Derby. ( 10.2 pounds) 


    I can also come on your boat and turn you into a fishing machine in no time... I wish i did that, rather then learn things the Hard way.


    I  have written four books. One American loser, was made into a movie by Loins Gate and was on HBO for a year.. it stars Stifler ( American Pie) , and Jeff Garland from Curb Your Enthusiasm .  2 books  on fishing that became amazon best sellers. Caught, And most Recently: And Then They All Puked. All are on Amazon. if book, ill give you free signed copy. 

    Top-Notch Equipment

    Top-Notch Equipment

    Top-Notch Equipment

    I use a 1993, 26 foot sturdy/proven Shamrock cudy cabin. With a 2003 Yanmar diesel.  With fair conditions boat cruises at a real 16 knots, in bad weather she will get us home dry at 12knots..this is a lot faster than most charter boats , that cruise at 10 knots. I can get to Block island where the fish are in 45 minutes.

    I fish early in April for black fish and cod, and late into December for Black fish, Sea bass and cod. Summer huge striped bass,fluke, sea bass occasionally tuna. 


    Again, dont listen to me watch my YOUTUBE videos, view 2023 pics. ask around. 


      

    Video

    We try to get kids interested early

    Meet Captain Jeff

    We try to get kids interested early

    Secondchoicecharters Montauk

    Contact Us

    Get in Touch!

    Attach Files
    Attachments (0)

    This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

    Better yet, see us in person!

    Send us a message with any comments, questions, or scheduling concerns. We will get back to you soon!

    Crazy Jeff's fishing excursions

    Hours

    Open today

    09:00 am – 05:00 pm

    Social

    Subscribe

    Sign up to hear from us about specials, sales, and events.

    Escape to Paradise with Crazy Jeff's fishing excursions Boat Charters - Experience the Ultimate Relaxation

      Copyright © 2025 Crazy Jeff's fishing excursions - All Rights Reserved.

      Powered by

      This website uses cookies.

      We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

      Accept